Episode 161: What Should Christian Women Know About Yesteryear?

By

Mama Bear Apologetics

Listen now

ShowNotes

In this special “mamas only” episode, Amy and Anja Westerhaus tackle Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke, a novel centered on Natalie, a wildly successful “tradwife” influencer whose carefully curated online persona masks a deeply dysfunctional reality.

Rather than treating the novel’s depiction of faith, marriage, motherhood, and conservative Christianity at face value, Amy and Anja encourage listeners to recognize Natalie as an unreliable narrator. They argue that her pursuit of the perfect home, marriage, family, and online identity reflects a works-based and performative worldview rather than biblical Christianity.

The conversation uses Yesteryear as a jumping-off point for a bigger question: What happens when an aesthetic becomes confused with biblical womanhood? The hosts distinguish between pursuing Christ and pursuing an image of perfection—whether that image involves sourdough, prairie dresses, homesteading, picture-perfect children, or an Instagram-worthy kitchen.

They also turn the critique inward. Christians aren’t immune to comparison, envy, trolling, labeling, or an “us versus them” mentality. Instead, believers are called to treat people—including those with whom they strongly disagree—with dignity, kindness, gentleness, and respect.

Ultimately, Amy and Anja challenge Christian women not to respond to caricatures of Christianity with another caricature. Instead, live differently. Biblical womanhood isn’t a social-media aesthetic or a one-size-fits-all lifestyle. It is faithfulness to Christ expressed through the particular gifts, relationships, responsibilities, and circumstances God has given each woman.

Main Points Covered

Tradwife Aesthetics vs. Biblical Womanhood — The hosts distinguish an online image of traditional femininity from biblical faithfulness.
Social Media & Performative Perfection — Curated content can fuel comparison, envy, and unrealistic expectations about motherhood and homemaking.
Works-Based Faith vs. Grace — Natalie’s pursuit of perfection is contrasted with salvation by grace and dependence on Christ.
Rejecting “Us vs. Them” Thinking — Christians are encouraged to resist caricatures, trolling, and dehumanizing labels and instead respond with love, gentleness, and respect.

Resources & Organizations Mentioned

Scriptures:

Ephesians 2:8–9
Luke 6:32–36
1 Peter 3:15
Ephesians 5:25

Thanks to Our Sponsors

Our Presenting Sponsor is American Heritage Girls: Visit americanheritagegirls.org/MBA to get a free parenting resource and learn more about what American Heritage Girls is doing.

Aqua Tru

Go to AquaTru.com now for 20% off your purifier using promo code MBA. AquaTru even comes with a 30-day best-tasting water guarantee.